A channel-by-channel read of where you stand against the 20 HVAC companies competing for Amarillo, what each gap is costing you, and what we'd do first.
49/100, #9 of 20 Amarillo HVAC companies. Your reputation is top-10 (4.9 stars, 172 reviews). Your visibility isn't: you get about 13 of ~2,500 local HVAC clicks a month; Gary's and Amarillo AC get about 350 each. Some of the companies beating you are weaker businesses than yours.
| Extra local clicks a month (half the gap to Gary's) | ≈176 |
| Clicks that become calls or forms | 10–20% |
| Leads that book a job | 35% |
| Extra booked jobs a month | 6–12 |
| Average job (repairs plus 1 in 10 system replacements) | $1,025 |
| Extra revenue a month | $6.3K–$12.6K |
| Gross profit at a 45% margin | $2.8K–$5.7K |
An illustration built on industry defaults, not your books and not a promise. Swap in your real close rate and ticket on the review call and the math updates.
Fix tracking in week one so every call is counted. Then Maps first, links second, money pages third, in that order, with every task in your portal. Details and the plan options are in Levers and What it takes.
The full report below has the evidence for every line here: eight channels, every competitor, keywords, the site crawl, links and sources.
Every number carries a label. We never present an estimate as a measurement, and we never guess where data exists.
Scores come from our Amarillo HVAC X-Ray, which scored all 20 companies on the same 8 channels. The colored bar is you, the green tick is the best in Amarillo, and the gray tick is the middle of the market.
Your reputation is a top-10 reputation and your Google profile is perfectly set up. But the two channels where Amarillo homeowners actually pick a company, Maps outside southwest Amarillo and Google search for anything without your name in it, are where you're furthest behind. That's why you get about 13 of the roughly 2,500 local HVAC clicks a month, while Gary's and Amarillo AC each get around 350.
The Maps pack is where most "near me" HVAC calls start. We searched "ac repair" from 25 points across Amarillo, 3 km apart, at 1:50 pm on a Tuesday while you were open.
| What we measured | You | Best in Amarillo |
|---|---|---|
| Top-3 spots, our 9-point X-Ray grid ("hvac" searches) | 1 of 9 | Gary's 6 of 9 |
| Top-3 spots, today's 25-point "ac repair" grid | 6 of 25 | — |
| Points where you don't show in the top 20 at all | 12 of 25 | — |
| "hvac repair" searched from central Amarillo | Not in top 20 | Gary's #1 |
| "ac repair" searched from SW Amarillo | #2 | Snow Bear #1 |
| Your modeled share of local HVAC clicks TOOL ESTIMATE | 0.5% | Gary's 14.7% |
Your Maps visibility stops about 6 km from the shop. You're #1–#3 across SW Amarillo, then fade north of I-40 and disappear across roughly the eastern half of the city. Google ranks Maps on distance, relevance and prominence. Distance you can't change, but relevance (pages, categories, posts for those parts of town) and prominence (reviews, links) you can, and those are exactly the channels below where you trail.
Your 4.9 stars come from reviews that name your techs: McKenzy, Mack ("Big Foot"), Josue, Patrick, Alex. That's rare and valuable. But the pace has collapsed just as the leader floored it.
| You | Gary's | Amarillo AC | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Total Google reviews | 172 | 2,334 | 633 |
| Rating | 4.9 | 4.9 | 5.0 |
| Newest review | ~2 months ago | Nov 11 | Nov 7 |
| Owner reply rate | 100% | 95% | 95% |
| Reply style | Same template every time | — | — |
Your one recent 1-star review is about a maintenance-plan visit that never got scheduled, which points to a process issue rather than workmanship.
About 30 reviews in the last 12 months, and none in roughly 60 days. Gary's adds about 150 a month, so the gap widens by more than 140 reviews every month. Review count and recency are among the strongest Maps signals you can control, This one is yours: we build and run the review system, but the ask has to come from your team at the end of every job.
We pulled every keyword your site ranks for and checked the money searches live, with three reads each.
| Site | Keywords ranked | Est. visits / month | Non-brand keywords in top 20 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Amarillo AC (amarilloair.com) | 1,689 | 2,889 | many |
| Gary's (garys.com) | 284 | 634 | many |
| You (samplehvac.com) | 121 | 48 | 9 |
| Sutton (suttonheatingandair.com) | 29 | 25 | — |
TOOL ESTIMATE Traffic and keyword counts come from DataForSEO, pulled Nov 17. Most of your 48 estimated visits are people already typing "Sample HVAC."
| Search | Searches / mo | Cost per ad click | Map pack | Top organic | You |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| hvac amarillo | 480 | $19.61 | Amarillo AC, Gary's, Bob Jay's | Gary's #3 | #19 |
| ac repair amarillo tx | 260 | $43.66 | Amarillo AC, Gary's, Bob Jay's | Amarillo AC #1 | not top 20 |
| ac repair amarillo | 210 | $18.53 | Amarillo AC, Gary's | Cooler Air Today #1 | not top 20 |
| air conditioning amarillo | 210 | $29.18 | Amarillo AC, Gary's, Bob Jay's | Gary's #1 | not top 20 |
| heating and air amarillo | 210 | $37.07 | Gary's, Amarillo AC, Hall's | Hall's #3 | #30 |
| furnace repair amarillo | ≈140 | ≈$18.53 | Gary's, Amarillo AC, Bob Jay's | Sutton #1 | not top 20 |
| hvac repair amarillo tx | 70 | $27.18 | — | — | #2 |
Volumes and costs per click: X-Ray keyword pull TOOL ESTIMATE. Positions: live Google reads, Nov 17 MEASURED. Sutton ranks #1 for furnace repair with only 29 keywords because it built a dedicated, 1,100-word page for each service.
About 1,500 searches a month for the core Amarillo HVAC terms, and you're on page 1 for one of them (70 searches). Each ad click on these terms costs $18–$44, so ranking organically for them is worth real money every month. The cause is in the next section: there's no page on your site built to win those searches.
We crawled every page in your sitemap and in your competitors' sitemaps, then counted the real words on each page, minus the menu and footer that repeat on every page.
| Pages (from each sitemap) | You | Gary's | Amarillo AC | Sutton |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Total pages in sitemap | 304 | 177 | 149 | 95 |
| Product / filter-shop pages | 190 | 9 | 0 | 2 |
| Service pages | 13 | ≈28 | 8 + 13 service-by-town | 34 |
| Avg words per service page | ≈800 | ≈930 | ≈900 | ≈1,140 |
| Town / neighborhood pages | 10 | 2 | 21 | 53 |
| Avg words per town page | ≈1,000 | ≈1,230 | ≈860 | ≈900 |
| Blog articles | 39 | 99 | 107 | 3 |
| Articles published or updated, last 12 months | 14 | 51 | 94 | 0 |
| …in the last 90 days | 3 | 2 | 86 | 0 |
| Pages with FAQ markup | 3 | 12 | 12 | 1 |
| Business markup (schema) on pages | Yes, site-wide | 68 pages | Yes, site-wide | Yes |
MEASURED Crawled Nov 17. Article dates come from each site's sitemap (published or last updated).
Your AC page (≈1,680 words) covers equipment. None of your pages is built around the repair and replacement searches homeowners actually type. Gary's, Sutton and Amarillo AC each have a page for each one.
190 product and filter pages are 62% of the site. That's fine for selling filters, but it gives Google a site that looks like a filter store more than a service company.
About 12 missing money pages at ~1,000 words each, plus service-by-town pages for Canyon, Bushland and the city's quadrants. That's roughly 25–35 pages, compared with the 30–50 the leaders already have. Your publishing pace (3 articles in 90 days) is a fraction of Amarillo AC's 86, and Amarillo AC's ~2,900 monthly visits are the result.
Links from other websites are how Google judges whether a business is trusted beyond its own site.
TOOL ESTIMATE Backlink index, Nov 17 (X-Ray counts for Caprock, Hall's and Scottco).
| You | Gary's | Amarillo AC | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Total links | 171 | 606 | 248 |
| Broken links (pointing at dead pages) | 30 | 0 | 1 |
| Spam score of linking sites | 31 | 13 | 20 |
| Domain strength (index rank) | 17 | 31 | 22 |
| Local trust links (Chamber, BBB, local news) | Chamber, BBB | Chamber, local TV, Carrier | — |
How we size it: you don't need to match Gary's link count, you need to out-quality it. Most of Gary's 309 linking sites are directories and press-release syndication. One DR 50+ editorial link carries roughly the weight of 3 of those ASSUMPTION, so the 194-site gap is about 65 quality links. Spread over 13 months, plus about 2 a month to keep pace, that's roughly 7 a month, all covered on the Market Leader plan.
Securing good links is slow, hands-on and the most costly part of the work, which is why it's the biggest line in the plan. We never use link farms or private blog networks.
About 200 fewer linking sites than Gary's, 30 links pointing at pages that no longer exist (easy wins once redirected), and a cluster of spammy foreign sites (Indonesia, Romania, Guatemala) that should be disavowed. Gary's has local TV and a manufacturer (Carrier) linking to it. You're a Trane, Mitsubishi, Amana, Goodman and Daikin dealer, and none of those dealer locators appear among the top linking sites we pulled.
| You | Gary's | Amarillo AC | Snow Bear | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Claimed, hours, website, categories | All set (7 categories) | All set (4) | All set (6) | All set (10) |
| Hours listed | Open 24 hours, 7 days | Business hours | Business hours | Business hours |
| Photos | 148 | 1,229 | 188 | 704 |
| Last Google post | Sep 3, 2026 (75 days) | Mar 20, 2026 | 5 days ago | Apr 14, 2026 |
| Posts in the last 60 days | 0 | 0 | 20 | 0 |
| Posts link to a blog article | Sometimes | Sometimes | Almost always | No |
MEASURED Google profile and posts, pulled Nov 17. Your June–September posts were weekly job write-ups, which is the right idea, and they stopped after Sep 3.
You're the only top-20 company listed as open 24 hours, and nothing on the profile says so in words: no post, no photo, no offer. Amarillo AC posts every few days and links each post to a fresh article, the same pattern behind its 2,900 monthly search visits. Photos: 148 vs Gary's 1,229. Every job your techs finish is a photo and a post you're not using.
| You | Frank's | Amarillo AC | Gary's | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Google search ads seen | 4 | 15 | 19 | 0 (stopped Feb 20) |
| Google Guaranteed (Local Services Ads) | Yes | Yes | Yes | No |
| Facebook / Instagram ads | No | Yes | No | No |
| Call tracking on the site | None | CallTrackingMetrics | CallTrackingMetrics | None |
| Ad tracking installed | None found | Google Ads, Meta | Google, Bing, ClickCease | None |
MEASURED X-Ray ads scan (Google Ads Transparency, Meta Ad Library, live LSA check). 8 Amarillo HVAC companies pay for the Google Guaranteed spot.
We have no Amarillo-specific figure, so we use national HVAC numbers and say so. Google Local Services Ads averaged $51 per HVAC lead in February 2026, against $149 for non-branded Google search ads. SearchLight's February 2026 HVAC LSA data also showed a 44.0% book rate and a $2,110 average ticket. Across December 2025, a unique LSA lead cost $54.05 and a paying customer cost $218.19. Expect Amarillo leads at $40 or more. Your actual cost per lead is the first thing we'd pull from your account.
You're in the right paid channels, but with no call tracking and no ad tracking on the site, nobody can say which dollars turn into jobs. The 4 search ads compete with 19 from Amarillo AC on terms that cost $18–$44 a click. Until tracking is fixed, adding budget is guessing.
| Asked "best HVAC company in Amarillo" | ChatGPT | Google AI Mode |
|---|---|---|
| Amarillo AC | #1 ("my first call") | #3 |
| Snow Bear | #2 | #4 |
| Gary's | #3 | #1 |
| Avalos | #4 | #5 |
| You | #5 | Not named |
MEASURED X-Ray AI check (one run per assistant, so treat it as a snapshot). 14 of the 20 Amarillo companies aren't named by either assistant.
The AI answers favor the same companies that publish the most (Amarillo AC) and have the most reviews (Gary's). Closing the content and review gaps above is also how you move up here.
Only 2 of the 20 Amarillo HVAC companies track calls. Without it, no report (ours included) can tell you which channel booked which job. It's the first thing we'd install, because every other number in this report gets better once your real data replaces our estimates.
Every gap above is real, but they don't move revenue equally. Here's the order we'd work them for Sample HVAC, based on where you sit (#9 of 20) and what's already strong.
Ask every happy customer for a Google review. Reviews are a major factor in Maps, and you're at zero for the last 60 days while Gary's adds about 150 a month. We build the system (texts, links, timing, reply handling) and track it in your portal, but the ask has to come from your techs at the end of every job. Your reviews already name McKenzy, Mack and Josue, so the habit is there. It just stopped.
*Time to impact uses placeholder ranges until our data-backed time-to-impact model is finished.
Think of the plan as a climb. This report is the map. The only question is how much help you want getting to the top.
Log in any time and see every task, page, post and link we've done, each one linked to the real thing. No cherry-picked monthly PDF.
Call tracking ties calls and booked jobs to the channel that produced them. You see revenue, not just rankings.
A delivery tracker in your portal counts every post, page and link against the plan, week by week.
We take one premium HVAC company in Amarillo. We are never building your competitor's rankings at the same time.
This report becomes your 12-month Playbook, ranked by fastest path to revenue. You always know what's next and why.
Cancel any time with 30 days' notice. We earn the next month every month.
Text Chase or Casey directly. Web Guy has been building websites and local search for West Texas businesses since 2006.
Proof: a Lubbock home-improvement client tracked 363 leads and about $700K in closed jobs in just over 7 months, every dollar in the portal.
Every plan is built from the gaps in your report: a base for the Maps, website and tracking work, plus the links your link gap needs. Your price and term are walked through on your review call, along with lighter options if you'd rather do part of the work yourself.
This is a sample. Real reports include the full plan, the price and a pays-for-itself calculator built on your own job values.
| Measure | Today | 90 days | 6 months | 12 months |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Maps top-3 spots (of 25) | 6 | 8–10 | 10–14 | 13–17 |
| Local HVAC clicks / mo EST. | ≈13 | 25–50 | 60–110 | 120–200 |
| Non-brand keywords in top 20 | 9 | 15–25 | 30–50 | 60–100 |
| Linking sites | 115 | ≈145 | ≈180 | ≈245 |
| Money pages live | 0 | 12 | 25+ | 35+ |
Ranges are targets built from this report's gaps, not guarantees. Rankings depend on Google and on what competitors do. We report every one of these monthly in your portal, against today's baseline.
That's it. About 15 minutes a week.
Ad spend is always extra. It adds to whichever plan you pick (or none) and goes straight to Google or Meta, never to us.
The plan above is built on organic: Maps, search and the links behind them. That's the part you own. Once you rank, every call is free, and it keeps working whether you spend a dollar that month or not. It takes a few months to build. Ads are the only thing that puts new calls on the board inside 30–45 days. They're rented: the calls stop the day the budget stops. So ads are optional, and how much depends on how patient you want to be.
| Channel | Cost per lead | Best for |
|---|---|---|
| Google Guaranteed (Local Services Ads) | $40–$60 | Ready-to-book calls. Pay per lead, not per click. Our first pick. |
| Google search ads | $104–$149 | Covering the searches Guaranteed misses. Amarillo clicks cost $18–$44, above the ~$9 national average MEASURED. |
| Facebook / Instagram | $35–$55 | Tune-up season and maintenance plans. Cheap leads, but they aren't in a hurry. Lowest priority. |
Guaranteed: $51 per HVAC lead, 44% book rate (SearchLight, Feb 2026, 409 HVAC accounts); $40 is the floor we see locally. Search: $104 blended, $149 non-brand (SearchLight, Jan 2026, 816 contractors). Facebook: $35–$55 for HVAC lead-form ads (HVAC Webmasters 2025). A paying customer cost $233 on Guaranteed vs $472 on search ads in the same data.
You already run Guaranteed and 4 search ads, but nothing on your site tracks which ones book jobs. Week one, we fix tracking. Only then do we recommend adding a dollar of ad budget. Organic stays the main plan either way: ads buy time while Maps and search catch up. We set up and manage ads inside your plan; the ad budget itself is paid straight to Google or Meta.
If your current data can't answer these, that's finding #9.
| Source | What it gave us | Label | Captured |
|---|---|---|---|
| Web Guy Market X-Ray, Amarillo HVAC | 20-company scores on 8 channels, 9-point Maps grid, ads, social, AI and tracking scans, keyword map | Measured / Tool est. | Nov 2026 |
| Google Maps 25-point grid ("ac repair") | Your rank at 25 points, 3 km apart, and who's #1 at each | Measured | Nov 17, ~1:50 pm |
| Google Maps live searches (2) | "hvac repair" from central and "ac repair" from SW Amarillo | Measured | Nov 17 |
| Google organic, 3 searches × 3 reads | Who ranks for ac repair, hvac company and furnace repair | Measured | Nov 17 |
| Google Business Profiles + post histories (4) | Categories, hours, photos, last post, post cadence | Measured | Nov 17 |
| Your 30 newest Google reviews | Pace, recency, reply style, tech names, complaint themes | Measured | Nov 17 |
| Full site crawls (4 sites, 725 pages) | Page types, words per page minus template, schema, FAQ markup, article dates | Measured | Nov 17 |
| DataForSEO ranked keywords + traffic (4 domains) | Keyword counts, estimated visits, non-brand positions | Tool estimate | Nov 17 |
| Backlink index (3 domains) | Linking sites, broken links, spam score, strength | Tool estimate | Nov 17 |
| SearchLight Digital via Enrich Labs / Elevarus; The Data-Driven Trades | National HVAC Local Services Ads cost per lead, book rate, cost per customer | National data | Feb 2026 / Dec 2025 |
Method: a finding leads a section only when at least two independent sources agree, or it's marked single-source. "Not found" claims are checked a second way before they're final. No impression counts are used. Two corrections from our first pass: your site does carry business markup, and you do run Google Guaranteed ads.
Powered by CodeTap AI
One platform, two weeks quiet.
MEASURED X-Ray social scan.
About a tenth of Gary's audience, on one platform instead of four, and only 5 Facebook recommendations against 172 Google reviews, so happy customers aren't being sent there. Social doesn't move Maps directly, but it's where homeowners double-check you, and it's where AI assistants increasingly look for proof a business is active.